San Francisco vs New York City: Which Is Better? (2023)

There is a common debate among people about which city is better between New York and San Francisco, two of the most popular and expensive cities in America.

In terms of living, both New York and San Francisco have their own unique perks and drawbacks. New York boasts an unparalleled energy and diversity that sets it apart from anywhere else, while San Francisco prides itself on being a cleaner and more relaxed city. Let’s take a closer look at the side-by-side comparison of New York versus San Francisco for the year 2023.

San Francisco vs New York Cost of Living

Both cities have a high cost of living, but New York is slightly more expensive. The cost of living in New York is 187% higher than the national average, whereas San Francisco is only about 116% higher. The median home price in all five boroughs of New York City is over $860,000, and in Manhattan, it is closer to $1.3 million. In San Francisco, the average home price is around $1.2 million, but there are cheaper cities nearby in the Bay Area. In terms of unemployment rates, San Francisco has a better rate of about 5.9%, compared to 8.8% in New York City.

San Francisco vs New York Weather

San Francisco boasts better weather than New York by most standards. The city’s location along the bay in Northern California provides a mild and temperate climate year-round, with minimal rainfall (and no snow). In contrast, New York experiences a full range of seasons, with spring and fall being optimal times to visit. However, summers and winters can be harsh, and it rains 47% more in New York than in San Francisco. While some may enjoy the seasonal changes in NYC, San Francisco’s climate consistently offers a more pleasant experience.

San Francisco vs New York Public Transportation

New York City boasts a well-known public transportation system that is faster and more efficient than San Francisco’s. The MTA system allows the city that never sleeps to commute throughout the night, and you can catch a subway train or bus anytime during the day. New York’s grid layout also makes it convenient to travel across town swiftly. On the other hand, San Francisco’s Muni system is also decent and offers a mix of buses, trains, and cable cars. However, due to its easy car navigation, more residents tend to drive in San Francisco. Additionally, Muni has limited hours of operation and doesn’t run all night.

San Francisco vs New York Job Opportunities

Both cities provide a diverse range of job opportunities in competitive fields. However, the industries they attract shape the job market differently. New York City offers a broad spectrum of job opportunities in finance, law, real estate, medicine, and technology. On the other hand, San Francisco is predominantly dominated by the technology sector, but it encompasses various disciplines within that space. Additionally, jobs in San Francisco pay an average of 3.8% more than in New York City.

San Francisco vs New York Cuisine & Lifestyle

Both cities boast an abundance of culture and cuisine, but if you’re seeking diversity, New York may be the better choice. With some of the world’s best restaurants representing nearly every ethnic group under the sun, it offers a unique melting pot culture that’s unmatched anywhere else on the planet. While San Francisco may not offer quite the same level of variety, it does have some of the best Asian cuisine in the country. When it comes to nightlife, New York offers glitz, glam, and an unparalleled energy, but it can also be pricey and crowded. That’s why many prefer the low-key vibe of San Francisco.

San Francisco vs New York Crime Rates

San Francisco and New York are two major cities that are considered relatively safe. However, San Francisco has a higher rate of property crime and violent crime compared to New York. According to the FBI data, San Francisco scored 79.2 for property crime and 39.6 for violent crime, while New York scored 24.9 for property crime and 28.2 for violent crime. Despite the recent uptick in crime due to the pandemic, New York is still considered one of the safest large cities in the US, provided that you take the necessary precautions. On the other hand, San Francisco is known for its large homeless population, which is a contributing factor to its higher crime rate.

San Francisco vs New York City Culture

When it comes to comparing New York and San Francisco, there are some noticeable differences in their culture and lifestyle choices. The Big Apple is known for its fast-paced environment and a culture that revolves around work and efficiency. On the other hand, San Francisco offers a laid-back atmosphere that provides a better work-life balance. While New York boasts of world-famous cultural attractions and a plethora of recreational activities that are available round the clock, San Francisco offers easy access to nature and beaches, with a slower pace of life that is more relaxed than the hustle and bustle of the city that never sleeps.

San Francisco vs New York Commute Times

According to a research study conducted by the US Census Bureau in 2017, the average commute time in New York was 35.9 minutes, which is slightly longer than San Francisco’s average of 32.1 minutes. However, New York City’s commute times have a wider range, with a higher number of 10-minute and 40-50-minute commutes compared to San Francisco’s predominance of 20-30-minute commutes.

San Francisco vs New York Quality of Life Index

According to a quality of life index created by Numbeo, San Francisco has a high score of 156, whereas New York’s score of 138 is considered moderate. The index takes into account various factors such as purchasing power, safety, healthcare, pollution, traffic, climate, and more. Although New York boasts a rich cultural scene and numerous opportunities, its population of over 8 million people has led to issues such as traffic and pollution. Additionally, the city is more expensive and has a harsher climate.

San Francisco vs New York Overall

In the debate between New York City and San Francisco as the better place to live, NYC takes the lead with lower crime rates, a more thrilling food scene, richer city culture, and better job prospects. However, the ultimate decision on which city is better for you depends on your personal preferences. Each city has its own set of pros and cons that appeal to different residents. New York is the world’s cultural and financial hub, providing unique opportunities that can’t be found anywhere else. On the other hand, San Francisco is the gem of the West Coast, offering many of the perks of New York minus the crowds and harsh weather. Ultimately, the decision comes down to whether you prefer sunny beaches or high fashion and a diverse culture.

New York vs. San Francisco Comparison Winner

Read More: Why Was Popcorn Ceiling Popular?